Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCRC Minutes 2026-09-24-SpecialMINUTES OF THE SPECIAL MEETING OF THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE SEPTEMBER 24, 2026 THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE OF THE CITY OF FRIENDSWOOD MET IN A SPECIAL MEETING ON THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2026, IN THE SECOND FLOOR (CMO) CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL, LOCATED AT 910 S. FRIENDSWOOD DRIVE, FRIENDSWOOD, TEXAS, WITH THE FOLLOWING MEMBERS PRESENT CONSTITUTING A QUORUM: Robin Hall Kitten Brizendine Yanne Belcher -Watson Ron Cox Dave Smith Joe Matranga Morad Kabiri Leticia Brysch Karen Horner Raquel Martinez 1. CALL TO ORDER Vice Chairperson Committee Member Committee Member Committee Member Committee Member Chairperson City Manager Assistant City Manager City Attorney City Secretary Chairperson Joe Matranga called the meeting to order with a quorum present at 9:01 A.M.; all members were present with the exception of Committee Member Madeline Short who was absent. 2. 'PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS Chairperson Joe Matranga noted there was no one who signed up to speak. 4. DISCUSSIONS A. Discuss the Friendswood City Charter, possible Charter amendments, and the Charter review process. The Committee proceeded to continue their review of Article III of the Charter. Members directed questions to staff for clarifications and thoughts. The Committee made the following observations and/or comments: • Section 3.01. City Council. o Discussion on the City Council term limits — Review proposed draft language that was provided to the Committee by the City Attorney Karen Horner. Charter Review Committee Special Meeting Minutes September 24, 2026 Page 2 of g Possible Language For Mayoral Term Limit Extension Sec. 3.01. Number, selection. term, and term limits. (a) Number and selection. The City Council shall be comprised of a Mayor and six Councilmembers. The Mayor and each Councilmember shall be elected from the City at large, and each shall occupy a position on the City Council. Councilmember positions shall be numbered 1 through 6 consecutively. (b) Length ofterms. The Mayor and each Councilmember serve three-year terms as PFeVided be)ew .t,_ .O (e) Term limits. 1. Councilmember term limit. (a) No person may serve as a Councilmember for more than four full three-year terms. (b) In calculating Councilmember term limits, the number of full three-year terms a person has served as Mayor shall count towards the term limits specified in subsection c.I (a). 2. Afavor term limit. (a) Except as provided in subsection c.2 (b), no person may serve as a Mayor for more than four full three-year terms. (b) If a person has previous service as a Councilmember, such person may serve as Mayor for the number of unnerved full Councilmember three-year terms remaining at the time the person becomes Mayor plus two additional full three-year terms. After a lengthy discussion related to the different possible scenarios that could occur as a result of amending the term limits for City Council and considering possibly removing term limitation all together, the Committee came to a consensus to table the discussion and revisit it at a later meeting date. Vice Chairperson Robin Hall requested staff provide a survey or conduct research on what other cities in the surrounding areas have adopted in regard to term limits before making a decision. • Section 3.02. Qualifications. o Discussion on proposed change below: In addition to any other qualifications prescribed by law, the Mayor and each councilmember shall Meet 4hR :. ,. Rf . h o..a'.1RS 6 n7. . :.o �, �....ua :_ ate., be a Qualified voter, and shall reside within the City while in office. Committee Member Dave Smith asked why they nixed that language in Section 3.02 for qualifications in regard to meeting conditions of subsections 6.02(a), items (1), (2), and (3). Assistant City Manager Leticia Brysch clarified that although the proposed language was recommended in 2022, it was not approved by the voters. It was the one ballot that failed. Charter Review Committee Special Meeting Minutes September 24, 2026 Page 3 of g Vice Chairperson Robin Hall inquired as to whether subsections 6.02(a), items (1), (2), and (3), could be moved to Section 3.02 of the Charter. Ms. Brysch stated that the language in subsection 6.02 of the Charter talks about how you are going to file for office, it is very detailed and believes it belongs with the Election component. The Committee members agreed that it is structured and makes no substantive change, therefore, they prefer to leave the section as it is written. • Section 3.03. Judge of election qualifications. Question asked as to whether the section refers to City Council being the final judge of elections and qualifications and are they authorized to make exceptions (i.e., if a candidate states their birth date to turn 21 is two days after the filing date or if they will be 21 by the election) Ms. Horner clarified that the section refers to the qualifications of its members, not of the candidates, such as if someone resides out of the city and intends to move back in — have they lost their residency — it refers to that nature of qualifications. • Section 3.04. Compensation. o Requested for staff to define "expenses" — What are "necessary expenses"? City Manager Morad Kabiri provided some examples of necessary expenses, such as City Council having to attend certain training, meetings, or events — they would get reimbursed for mileage and hotel fees, or if they are representatives of the City or have to make a presentation on behalf of the City and need to distribute copies. Some Councilmembers elect to get reimbursed while others do not. However, Mr. Kabiri noted he would err on the side of not asking for reimbursement because if I'm there and want to do something that's not really city -related, then I'm not beholden to those limitations, but it is left to each individual's ethics and personal decisions. o Discussion on whether the City should compensate its Councilmembers. Committee Member Kitten Brizendine referred to the handout the previous meeting related to a compensation and benefits survey conducted on surrounding cities. She stated that she was surprised by the pay rates being provided in other cities and assumed it would only cover expenses for mileage. Mr. Kabiri noted that for the record, he believes that the City's elected officials enjoy being able to say that they are not compensated because any amount that could or has been considered in the past for compensation would be inconsequential, considering the work, time and effort that they provide. Chairperson Matranga stated that if a Councilmember or candidate is in a situation where they need to be spending their time in earning and making money, being a member of the Council is not the place where they are going to make a lot of money, as these are not paid positions; and at best, it only provides for reimbursement for some Council -related expenses. o Discussion on whether to remove "upon approval by the Council," at the end of the section. Charter Review Committee Special Meeting Minutes September 24, 2026 Page 4 of Ms. Horner stated it is merely a cleanup item needed because of equal dignity. She stated that the country has its constitution and its related statutes, etc. Similar to that, the City has its Charter, its ordinances and resolutions, policies by resolution, etc., so equal dignity is needed for belts and suspenders to ensure that the Charter mirrors the City's policy and state law in regard to the allowance of the City Manager's expenditures. Ms. Homer further clarified that while it would be cleaner to remove this language, it is just for a cleanup effort, and there is no violation of anything because the Council adopted the Reimbursement Policy, and ergo the policy allows for us to pay council for those expenses in the first place. • Section 3.05. Mayor and Mayor Pro Tem. Discussion on removal of language, "The Mayor shall see that all resolutions of the City Council are faithfully obeyed and enforced." Mr. Kabiri indicated that it is not the Mayor's job, but rather his job as City Manager to ensure all resolutions of the City are faithfully obeyed and enforced. The Committee concurred with his statement. o Discussion on who can approve "official plats" instead of the Mayor — is it Planning and Zoning Commission? Mr. Kabiri stated that the Council had approved changes to the rules in a recent Council meeting. He noted that currently, depending on the plats, staff, in this case the Director of Community Development and the City Engineer may approve them administratively; however, certain plats do require the Planning and Zoning Commission to approve, and this requires the Commissioner Chair and Vice Chair to sign. He further noted that state law has changed within the last few years to allow for these types of approvals. Mr. Kabiri noted that if the applicant complies with the City's ordinances, under the law, the City is required to approve the submitted plat, and by allowing for these administrative approvals, it eliminates unnecessary bureaucracy with repetitive and unnecessary approvals, because ultimately the Planning and Zoning Commission cannot deny a plat that is in compliance with all applicable laws, and the provided amended language is merely a cleanup item. Discussion on proposed language: (b) Afa Pro Tem. The Mayor Pro Tem shall be a Councilmember elected by the City )or Council, at the next regulaf ra, r, neil meeting f 116'A iRg the eaRVIISSORg Of retkifflS and PFE) Tem shall act as mayor during the disability or absence of the Mayor; and in this capacity; shell have the rights and duties conferred upon the Mayor. This proposed revision removes the time period for the selection of the Mayor Pro Tem to be in line with actual practices. Ms. Horner stated that the City Council usually discusses the election of the Mayor Pro Tem along with the Council liaison appointments at its summer retreat, which is held in July. She further noted that in the Council's Rules of Procedure, the Council has added the position of a Vice Mayor Pro Tem, who can be appointed by the Mayor as needed, especially in an emergency situation. • Section 3.06. Vacancies, forfeiture, filling of vacancies. o Discussion on the meaning of "excused by the Council" as it relates to attendance at City Council meetings in Section 3.06(b)(4). Charter Review Committee Special Meeting Minutes September 24, 2026 Page 5 of il Mr. Kabiri stated that as written the intent of the section means that the Council would have to vote on whether or not to excuse the absence of a councilmember; however, this duty has been relegated to the Mayor pursuant to the Council's Rules of Procedure to allow for the Mayor or the City Manager to excuse a Councilmember's absence if said absence is communicated in advance. Mr. Kabiri stated that this is being done to ensure councilmembers are not routinely just missing council meetings for the sake of missing council meetings and to remove politics from whether or not someone is excused for missing a meeting. o Discussion on the removal of "upon an affirmative vote of five (5) or more members of City Council" from Section 3.06(c), related to filling vacancies. Ms. Homer relayed that the proposed language is merely a cleanup item and removes the requirement of having five members or more to approve any item and instead requires only a simple majority. • Section 3.08. Prohibitions. Discussion on the proposed language for Section 3.08(b), "Appointments and removals," — The City Manager hires Department Heads with the concurrence of City Council, but can remove a Department Head without their concurrence. Mr. Kabiri indicated that as currently written, concurrence is still needed from City Council to suspend or fie a Department Head which results in a timing issue when someone needs to be removed quickly and the logistics of calling a special Council meeting to seek said concurrence may prolong an already difficult situation that could then unnecessarily be turned into a political issue. He further noted that a City Manager that is charged with administering the operations of the City that does not have the ability to suspend or fire an employee with cause, they are somewhat hamstrung and can be a liability depending on the circumstances. Mr. Kabiri further stated that the steps they have to go through to terminate a Department Head, which many times has included outside reviews and investigations, is not an easy process and is not as simple as just getting rid of somebody without cause. For the sake of transparency, they would communicate the employee issues, the facts of the situation and options moving forward to the Mayor and Council, and not only as it relates to Department Heads, but also of any employees that have a strong relationship with Councilmembers due to the nature of their job. He further stated that there have been times when the employee in question threatened the City with litigation and their attorney would meet with the staff and after reviewing the information, they would simply state that there was no case and walked away, and the employee chose to resign. o Discussion on the term "City Officer" in Section 3.08(c) —Possible removal. Committee Member Smith indicated he is looking at it from the standpoint of the term, "City Officer," referring to someone who has particular authority to be able to do something on behalf of the City, a City Engineer or Fire Marshal, but does not apply to a board or committee member. The consensus of the Committee was to remove the term as there is not an Officer that is not an employee of the City. Discussion on proposed new language for Section 3.08(d), "Disclosing confidential information" Ms. Homer indicated she would bring back some revised language for the sake of clarity. Charter Review Committee Special Meeting Minutes September 24, 2026 Page 6 of g • Section 3.10. Rules of procedure. o Asked if the Council's Rules of Procedure are available for public view. Mr. Kabiri noted that the Rules of Procedure are available on the City's website and in Laserfiche through the repository of resolutions. Discussion on the addition of the term "regular" as it relates to citizen having a reasonable opportunity to be heard at any meeting. Ms. Horner relayed that the new language provides Council the freedom to elect if they want to have a public comment period during a budget workshop or retreat. She noted that the statute indicates you have to give people an opportunity to talk about an item before you take a vote on it, but in a workshop, Council is not taking a vote on anything so that would be consistent with the statute. However, if there is an item on a special meeting agenda that requires a vote, then we would add the public comment. Committee Member Smith suggested wording it to imply that they would have a reasonable opportunity to be heard at any meeting, including but not limited to those matters for action. Ms. Horner stated she would look at Open Meetings Act to take some language from there or just leave it out altogether. Chairperson Matranga indicated that this language is not alluding that an individual cannot attend any meeting, workshop or retreat, but rather on their ability to be able to speak during a public session. However, he believes it might be taken out of context and is not worth making the change as it does not happen enough to be problematic. The consensus of the Committee was to remove the term "regular" before meeting. The Committee recessed for a break at 10:42 a.m., and reconvened at 10:50 a.m. • Section 3.11. Ordinances in general. o Discussion on the requirement of two readings for certain ordinances per Section 3.11(c) Ms. Horner indicated that the proposed language is regarding removing the limitation of having to read the ordinance captions as that will allow them to have more flexibility on the agenda to put second readings under Consent Agenda if there were no issues at the first reading. Currently, we are not complying with our Charter because we do not read the entire caption of an ordinance, so it is an administrative cleanup, but also a compliance issue. The Committee consented to replace the term "readings" with "considerations." • Section 3.12. Emergency ordinances. Discussion on removing the number "five" of Councilmembers needed to vote on emergency ordinances. Chairperson Matranga suggested stating "the affirmative vote of a majority of the Council present" as you would not necessarily have the normal quorum during emergency situations. Ms. Horner stated that change would have to be consistent throughout the Charter. Charter Review Committee Special Meeting Minutes September 24, 2026 Page 7 of 8 • Section 3.13. Codes of technical regulations. o Discussion on the removal of all language under Section 3.13, with the exception of. "Copies of any adopted code of technical regulations shall be made available by the City Secretary in compliance with law. " Chairperson Matranga suggested adding "upon written request" at the end of the section; however, Ms. Brysch cautioned that it would bring up the Public Information Act and that copyright laws would apply. Ms. Brysch stated that they err on providing customer service, as the Public Information Act and making it official in writing tends to be more if it is for a voluminous request that will require a lot of staff time. Ms. Horner further clarified that the current proposal was to remove the entire section and the Committee consented to the deletion of this section. • Section 3.14. Authentication and recording, codification, printing. o Discussion on the prescribed time of codification of the Charter being "within one year after adoption of this Charter and at least every ten years thereafter," as well as removing the term "printing," from the section title. Ms. Horner indicated that she believes that the City Code needs to be updated regularly in order to ensure compliance with the law, as they do not have to wait ten years to do a whole revamping or recodification of the Code. She further noted that codes need continuous and regular updates and codified, so updates are available online as they are approved, which provides easy and quick access for users. Ms. Homer also noted that she did not believe that a prescribed period of time for a recodification process is really necessary because it is an added expense, which does not ensure a good product from a third party, which is why she will be completing the City's recodification in-house. As it relates to the printing requirement, Ms. Brysch noted that most departments have turned in their physical Code books and utilize the online version, it is all digital now and a waste of funds to have to print copies of updated portions of the Code, which are not used. The Committee concurred with the assessment. • Section 3.15. Bonds for City Employees. o Discussion on whether the City Manager should be listed under this section along with the Finance Director or remain within the City Manager portion, Section 4.01(a). Ms. Homer cautioned against having bond requirements in multiple places in order to avoid inconsistency if amended in one section and not the others. Mr. Kabiri explained that the bond in question covers all acting personnel for the positions of City Manager and Finance Director and the bond amount has remained the same as originally approved. Vice -Chairperson Hall referred to Section 3.14(d), where it alludes to City Council being able to "adopt an ordinance that corrects errors in spelling, cross-references, punctuation, non -substantive revisions/reorganizations or numbering of articles or section in the Charter" without approval of the voters. She asked if this had been done before or would any of these proposed changes fall under these categories. Mr. Kabiri indicated that all changes have been made in conjunction with the Charter review timeline. Charter Review Committee Special Meeting Minutes September 24, 2026 Page S of S Ms. Homer stated that they would have to review the list to ensure any revision isn't substantive and would not change any provisions. • Section 3.16. Investigation by the City Council. o Discussion on increasing the amount of fine to "$1,000" versus "$100," per violation. The Committee's consensus is to set the amount of fine per violation to $500. 5. CLOSING COMMENTS & NEXT MEETING A. Consider setting up any tasks and/or processes for the next regularly scheduled Charter Review Committee meeting. Since several of the Committee Members would not be in attendance at the next regularly scheduled meeting on Thursday, October 8, 2026, the Committee's consensus was to cancel the October 8' meeting and meet at the following regularly scheduled meeting to be held on Thursday, October 15, 2026, at 4:30 p.m. Chairperson Matranga stated they would discuss Articles IV, VI, and VII of the Charter for the next regular meeting scheduled for Thursday, October 15, 2026, at 4:30 p.m. in the Second Floor CMO Large Conference Room. The Committee will discuss Article V of the Charter at a later meeting date. 6. ADJOURNMENT With there being no further business to discuss, Chairperson Matranga adjourned the September 24, 2026, Charter Review Committee Special Meeting at 11:27 A.M. Attest: O� FFt1ENpS� 00 Raq el nez, Inez, ity RSec t ) v Ur sTq� OF: I