Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCRC Minutes 2026-09-03-ReqularMINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE SEPTEMBER 3, 2026 THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE OF THE CITY OF FRIENDSWOOD MET IN A REGULAR MEETING ON THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 3, 2026, IN THE SECOND FLOOR (CMO) CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL, LOCATED AT 910 S. FRIENDSWOOD DRIVE, FRIENDSWOOD, TEXAS, WITH THE FOLLOWING MEMBERS PRESENT CONSTITUTING A QUORUM: Robin Hall Kitten Brizendine Yanne Belcher -Watson Madeline Short Ron Cox Dave Smith Joe Matranga Morad Kabiri Karen Homer Raquel Martinez 1. CALL TO ORDER Vice Chairperson Committee Member Committee Member Committee Member Committee Member Committee Member Chairperson City Manager City Attorney City Secretary Chairperson Joe Matranga called the meeting to order with a quorum present at 4:30 P.M.; all members were present. 2. PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS Chairperson Matranga noted there was no one who signed up to speak. U 1-1►vtI 1Y D[.y A. Consider approving the minutes of the Charter Review Committee Regular Meeting held on August 18, 2026. Committee Member Kitten Brizendine made a motion to approve the minutes of the Charter Review Committee Regular Meeting held on August 18, 2026. Committee Member Ron Cox seconded the motion. The vote was the following: Ayes: Chairperson Joe Matranga, Vice Chairperson Robin Hall, Committee Member Kitten Brizendine, Committee Member Yanne Belcher -Watson, Committee Member Madeline Short, Committee Member Ron Cox, and Committee Member Dave Smith Nays: None The item passed unanimously. Charter Review Committee Meeting Minutes September 3, 2026 Page 2 of 5 4. BUSINESS TI'EMS A. Consider setting a schedule for the Charter Review Committee's regular meetings. Chairperson Joe Matranga relayed that action on this item had been postponed at the last Charter Review Committee Meeting in order to confirm that the proposed meeting schedule would accommodate all the committee members' schedules. The proposed dates and times presented were Thursdays from 4:30 p.m. to 6:00 p.m., on: • September 3, 2026, • September 17, 2026, • October 8, 2026, • October 15, 2026, • October 29, 2026, • November 4, 2026 (Wednesday), • November 19, 2026, • December 10, 2026, and • December 17, 2026. Committee Member Ron Cox made a motion to approve the meeting schedule as presented with the meeting time beginning at 4:30 p.m. Committee Member Madeline Short seconded the motion. The vote was the following: Ayes: Chairperson Joe Matranga, Vice Chairperson Robin Hall, Committee Member Kitten Brizendine, Committee Member Yanne Belcher -Watson, Committee Member Madeline Short, Committee Member Ron Cox, and Committee Member Dave Smith Nays: None The item passed unanimously. 5. DISCUSSIONS A. Discuss the Friendswood City Charter, possible Charter amendments, and the Charter review process. Chairperson Joe Matranga asked the Committee how it would prefer to handle the Charter review process. Vice Chairperson Robin Hall indicated that the prior Charter Review Committee reviewed each section individually, allowing members to raise possible amendments, concerns, or questions, and that the approach had worked well. City Attorney Karen Homer pointed out that the handouts provided in the members' binders included proposed revisions identified by staff for the Committee's consideration. The Committee reviewed Sections 1.00 through 2.07 of the Charter. Members directed questions to staff for clarifications and thoughts. The Committee made the following observations and/or comments: Charter Review Committee Meeting Minutes September 3, 2026 Page 3 of 5 • Section 1.00. Glossary of Terms. o Should a definition for "Deputy City Manager" and "Assistant City Managers?" be added to this section as they have added a level in city management? City Manager Morad Kabiri recommended against defining those terms, as positions evolve and an individual may serve simultaneously as a department head and an Assistant City Manager. o Clarify that department heads are appointed by the City Manager "and approved" or "with Council concurrence" by City Council? City Manager Kabiri explained that offers are made contingent upon Council concurrence. If Council were to decline a candidate, he would present another candidate for Council's concurrence, but that has never happened. Committee Members agreed to just reference Section 4.01(d)(2) of administrative rules where it states that Council "concurs." o Definition of an "Officer" — Should they define advisory and discretionary and what those mean as far as decision making power, approval power? Committee Member Dave Smith indicated that by being members of this committee, or any other advisory committee, they are not officers of the City. This section defines what an officer is, which means council has delegated certain authorities to those members of the committee and there are certain liabilities associated with being an officer of the City, such as Construction Board of Appeals (CBOA) and Friendswood Downtown Economic Development Corporation (FDEDC). Ms. Horner indicated the FDEDC is a separate entity, a component unit, but like the Planning and Zoning Commission, they have discretionary authority. She stated that Council has categorized advisory and non -advisory committees in Chapter 2 of the Code of Ordinances • Section 1.01. Incorporation. o Remove reference to "Galveston County" • Section 1.02. Form of government. o Charter references both a "Council -Manager Government" and "Home -Rule City" — Should there be consistency and get added to the Glossary of Terms in Section 1.00? We are both. Ms. Horner indicated those are statutorily defined, well-known terms that do not need to be redefined, but the Committee can recommend that the editor's notes include a reference to the applicable statutes if desired. Vice Chairperson Hall noted this may be a ballot proposition, as those terms may not be so common to the general public. o References that City Council shall appoint the City Manager but does not reference "City Attorney or Municipal Judge" Committee Member Smith suggested that the Committee look at context of paragraph, as it designates, the form of government and clarifies how the council relates to the city manager, not to these other positions. Charter Review Committee Meeting Minutes September 3, 2026 Page 4 of 5 Therefore, adding references to the city attorney and municipal court judge in this context would expand the scope and suggest that the city manager, city attorney, and municipal court judge are all part of the council-manager form of government, which they are not. Vice Chairperson Hall noted that Section 4.03 refers to the city attorney and states the Council shall appoint a competent and duly qualified and licensed practicing attorney in the State of Texas. • Section 1.03. Boundaries. o Remove "in all annexation ordinances and proceedings of the City ofFriendswood, Texas" at end of paragraph in order to simplify as there are other ways to change boundaries. • Section 2.01. General powers. o Include dispose of in following phrase at end of paragraph, "including the power to acquire or dispose of property within Galveston, Harris, and Brazoria Counties. o Adjust capitalization of "Home Rule" throughout Charter. • Section 2.02. Change of boundaries and annexation of territory. o Consider using the word "disannex" where it references "detach". o Should there be consistency in referring to "disannexations" as in other sections? o Clean up section by simply stating "in accordance with state law " o Remove "In addition," at the beginning of second paragraph and start with "The City shall" or leave phrase "to the power to annex all additional property for all purposes" — It's really a non - substantive change. Ms. Horner indicated that the last sentence of the section addresses fixing, altering, and extending boundaries, which could include disannexation or annexation. She stated this section pertains to boundaries only, not the City's ownership of or right to acquire property. The next section, regarding eminent domain, references the City's authority to own property or to acquiring property from others. • Section 2.03. Eminent Domain. o Better to reference state law, as the Charter is not currently more restrictive than state law. o Include phrase that states "including, but not limited to." o City Attorney will bring back proposed language. Ms. Homer stated that the City must comply with state law regardless, and she did not believe anything in the Charter currently is more restrictive than state law. She noted that subsection (b) appears to mirror some state law requirements and suggested that, to avoid the need for ongoing amendments as state law changes, the section simply could state that the City has the power of eminent domain to the extent allowed by state law. Additionally, editor's notes could be revised to include a reference to the applicable state law. • Section 2.04. Streets and public property. o Too many uses of the word "public" — Can we just say "public" one time, or is it too ambiguous? Grammatical issue? Charter Review Committee Meeting Minutes September 3, 2026 Page 5 of 5 o City Attorney will bring back proposed language. • Section 2.05. Street development and improvements. o Does not state "in accordance with state law" as in other sections. Ms. Homer noted that the phrase "in accordance with law" captures compliance with both state and federal law. • Section 2.06. Limitation of Liability for damages. o Be consistent when it references time periods (i.e., "6 months" versus "100 days," or "80 days" — Verify with Texas Tort Claims Act (TTCA) and minor that language. Provide a flow chart. • Section 2.07. Zoning. o Proposed change due to state law —Remove "and legislative bodies thereof by V.T.C.A., Local Government Code § 211.001 et.seq., and all amendments thereto and amendments which may hereafter be made thereto, " at end of section. The consensus of the Committee was for City Attorney Karen Horner to bring back all of the noted revisions and proposed language changes after the first complete review of the Charter in order to move along the review process. 6. CLOSING COMMENTS & NEXT MEETING A. Consider setting up any tasks and/or processes for the next regularly scheduled Charter Review Committee meeting. Chairperson Matranga stated that their homework was to read and study Sections 3.00 through 3.17 of the Charter for the next meeting scheduled for Thursday, September 17, 2026, from 4:30 p.m. in the Second Floor CMO Large Conference Room. 8. ADJOURNMENT With there being no further business to discuss, Chairperson Matranga adjourned the September 3, 2026, Charter Review Committee Meeting at 5:47 P.M. Attest: Raq 1 ac 'nez, TRMC, City Sec s P� 7 OF,