HomeMy WebLinkAboutCRC Minutes 2026-09-17-RegularMINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE
CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE
SEPTEM 3ER 17, 2026
THE CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE OF THE CITY OF FRIENDSWOOD MET IN A REGULAR
MEETING ON THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 17, 2026, IN THE SECOND FLOOR (CMO)
CONFERENCE ROOM, CITY HALL, LOCATED AT 910 S. FRIENDSWOOD DRIVE,
FRIENDSWOOD, TEXAS, WITH THE FOLLOWING MEMBERS PRESENT CONSTITUTING A
QUORUM:
Robin Hall
Kitten Brizendine
Yanne Belcher -Watson
Madeline Short
Ron Cox
Dave Smith
Joe Matranga
Leticia Brysch
Karen Horner
Raquel Martinez
1. CALL TO ORDER
Vice Chairperson
Committee Member
Committee Member
Committee Member
Committee Member
Committee Member
Chairperson
Assistant City Manager
City Attorney
City Secretary
Chairperson Joe Matranga called the meeting to order with a quorum present at 4:31 P.M.; all members
were present.
2. PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS
Assistant City Manager Leticia Brysch noted there was no one who signed up to speak; however, Mr.
Chapman had introduced himself to the Committee prior to the commencement of the meeting.
3. MINUTES
A. Consider approving the minutes of the Charter Review Committee Regular Meeting held on
September 3, 2026.
Committee Member Kitten Brizendine made a motion to approve the minutes of the Charter Review
Committee Regular Meeting held on September 3, 2026. Vice Chairperson Robin Hall seconded the
motion. The vote was the following:
Ayes: Chairperson Joe Matranga, Vice Chairperson Robin Hall, Committee Member Kitten
Brizendine, Committee Member Yanne Belcher -Watson, Committee Member Madeline
Short, Committee Member Ron Cox, and Committee Member Dave Smith
Nays: None
Charter Review Committee Meeting Minutes
September 17, 2026
Page 2 of 5
The item passed unanimously.
4. DISCUSSIONS
A. Discuss the Friendswood City Charter, possible Charter amendments, and the Charter review
process.
The Committee proceeded to review Article III of the Charter. Members directed questions to staff for
clarifications and thoughts.
The Committee made the following observations and/or comments:
• Section 3.01. City Council.
o Discussion on the pros and cons on what it means to have At -Large versus Single -Member
Districts.
City Attorney Karen Homer provided the Committee with a quick overview of single -member districts.
For single -member districts, Courts determine if such districts impede the ability of minority votes to elect
representatives of their choice. Specifically, Courts (i) identify if a minority group is sufficiently large
and geographically compact to constitute a majority in a single -member district; (ii) see if the minority
group is politically cohesive, and (iii) consider whether the white majority vote sufficiently serves as a
bloc, thus enabling it, in the absence of special circumstances, to defeat a minority group's preferred
candidate. Ms. Horner stated that when looking at single -member districts, it would require them to look
at the different district boundaries to make sure that the minority vote is not diluted.
Assistant City Manager Leticia Brysch relayed that in her experience as an elections administrator in past
cities, those that had single -member districts had a minority group concentrated in a specific area of the
city to create a voting bloc. Any time that there was a census, a consultant was hired to assess the
geography, the locations and the concentration of minority groups and to make sure that however the maps
were re -drawn, they did not dilute that minority voting blocs. Ms. Brysch noted that Friendswood does
not currently have a geographical area of the city that has a large concentration of one minority group,
hence, single -member districts would not necessarily be required or needed. She further noted, based on
her experience, that single -member districts sometimes prohibited the Council from making the best
decisions for the totality of the community as some single -member district councilmembers become more
focused on their specific districts and not on the needs of the entire city.
Committee Member Dave Smith noted that the only issue that could be of significant consideration is the
perceived difference in which residents on the Harris County side feel that they are not treated equally to
those on the Galveston County side; and so if there was a single -member district specific to Harris County,
they would always have a member of Council that represented them. However, it would always seem like
it would be six against one and could cause a divide on Council.
Committee Member Kitten Brizendine indicated that another issue that could result from a single -member
district could be if there is no one that is willing to run for Council. She stated that currently, anyone can
run that is within the city's boundaries and they represent the entire city, which she feels is the most
important thing, the representation of all citizens.
Charter Review Committee Meeting Minutes
September 17, 2026
Page 3 of 5
Committee Member Ron Cox noted that the City of La Porte recently incorporated Shore Acres in the past
year and by virtue of that, they are having to redraw their district boundaries. Once those district
boundaries are redrawn, they have to hold an election for the entire Council as opposed to just those that
are affected, so essentially their entire Council has to be re-elected.
Vice Chairperson Robin Hall stated that a recurring issue she has heard is that people feel they are not
represented properly and they do not have a voice, so she wanted to discuss the pros and cons for single -
member districts versus at -large. She agreed with a lot of the points that had been said as to why they
would not change to single -member districts. Chairperson Joe Matranga agreed and noted that as a former
Councilmember, he believed that currently there are seven people that care what happens on the Harris
County side of the city and also about the entire city. The consensus from the Committee was to not move
forward with a recommendation to consider the creation of single -member districts.
o Discussion on the City Council term limits — vague as written "no person shall be elected to
serve on the City Council in any capacity for more than four three-year terms."
Vice Chairperson Hall indicated that she wanted to clarify this language to conform with the intent of the
Committee that presented the original language that no person can serve on the council in any capacity
for more than 12 years in total. Committee Member Smith stated there are multiple topics to be considered
under this one item, including (1) does it need to be changed for clarification purposes, (2) if it does, which
direction is the best way to go, and (3) what is the best recommendation for Council?
Ms. Brysch pointed out that the language as it currently reads does not meet the intent of what the
Committee and can be misinterpreted. She noted Ms. Homer's language provided in the red lined stating
that "no person shall be elected to serve on the City Council in any capacity for more than four full or
ap rtia[ three-year terms" would meet the original intent.
Committee Member Smith stated that he understood the ballot language on this item to mean that a person
could not serve for more than a cumulative total of 12 years, but he can now see that as it is written, it
could be open to someone else's opinion. He stated that the provided, red -lined language, makes the partial
terms count as a term, so it is possible that a person could be limited to only 10 years of service, which
Ms. Homer confirmed. He went on to relay that past Charter reviews have prompted the discussion that
there is a difference between serving as a Councilmember and as a Mayor, and he believed that the most
prepared persons to serve as Mayor are those that have already served as a Councilmember, and felt that
limiting someone to 12 years, it is likely that this limits a potential Mayor to serve only 9 years because
of the years they would have already served as a councilmember. Committee Member Brizendine agreed
and stated that the dais benefited from the history and continuity of an experienced person to serve as
Mayor, and they wouldn't like councilmembers to be penalized for serving partial terms. Committee
Member Smith noted this has happened several times in history, where someone would leave a
Councilmember seat to run for Mayor, leaving a partial term unfulfilled, which under the current language
would then limit that individual's years of service. Committee Member Maddie Short asked a point of
clarification as to whether he was suggesting splitting the terms of service for a Mayor from those of a
Councilmember.
The Committee discussed the pros and cons of having partial terms count against them as it relates to term
limits, on having term limits all and whether or not to consider the Mayor terms and Councilmember terms
Charter Review Committee Meeting Minutes
September 17, 2026
Page 4 of 5
limits separately. Chairperson Matranga stated that in Friendswood's form of government, where we have
a strong City Manager and a weak Mayor situation, although it is an important job, they only have one
vote as the rest of Council, and that position should not get a whole other reset count of terms. He
suggested that they extend the terms if you are elected to be Mayor after serving on Council, and that an
individual should not get penalized for serving partial terms on Council.
The Committee discussed the resign -to -run provisions and their resulting vacancies, and the timelines and
challenges to holding a special election to fill said vacancies.
Committee Member Smith reiterated that he would not want the language in this section to reduce the
terms of office from a total of 12 years, he would want an incumbent to serve four full three-year terns
and not get penalized for partial terms of office served.
As the item at hand was not settled, the consensus of the Committee was to schedule a special meeting
before the next regularly scheduled meeting to complete this discussion.
Vice Chairperson Robin Hall made a motion to schedule a Charter Review Committee Special Meeting
on Thursday, September 24, 2026, beginning at 9:00 a.m. Committee Member Kitten Brizendine seconded
the motion. The vote was the following:
Ayes: Chairperson Joe Matranga, Vice Chairperson Robin Hall, Committee Member Kitten
Brizendine, Committee Member Yanne Belcher -Watson, Committee Member Madeline
Short, Committee Member Ron Cox, and Committee Member Dave Smith
Nays: None
The item passed unanimously.
Further discussion ensued as it related to determining the term limitations for the capacity to serve as
Mayor when you have previously served as a Councilmember.
Ms. Brysch asked if the Committee was looking to keep the four full three-year terms and ensuring that
members of council would not be penalized by partial terms, which the Committee confirmed. Ms. Homer
stated that they can talk in terms of election or in terms of service, instead of being "elected," they might
need to discuss how long they actually serve. Committee Member Smith confirmed that the extension in
terms would only apply if an incumbent made the change to serve from Councilmember to Mayor position,
but they could not then step back to a Councilmember position.
Committee Member Short believed a term limit of 12 years is light, but 24 years is too long. Committee
Member Smith indicated that it is incumbent upon the community and those that are in those positions to
turn it over to a different perspective, to a new way of thinking, a new set of fresh eyes, to a younger
generation. However, he does not like the loss of historical knowledge or institutional knowledge that
goes away with someone who would have been a really good mayoral candidate.
After a brief discussion, Ms. Horner asked for point of clarification as far as what the Committee wanted
for draft language related to term limits. The Committee's direction was for Councilmembers to be able
to be elected to serve the full four three-year terms, excluding partial terms, and anyone that wanted to
Charter Review Committee Meeting Minutes
September I7, 2026
Page 5 of 5
then run for Mayor, would be able to for two more full three-year terms. This option would help move
experienced councilmembers into the Mayor position. Ms. Horner indicated that she would provide the
Committee with some draft language for the desired terms before the scheduled special meeting.
5. CLOSING COMMENTS & NEXT MEETING
A. Consider setting up any tasks and/or processes for the next regularly scheduled Charter Review
Committee meeting.
Chairperson Matranga stated they would continue to discuss Article III of the Charter for the next special
meeting scheduled for Thursday, September 24, 2026, at 9:00 a.m. in the Second Floor CMO Large
Conference Room.
1 1 t►ul
With there being no further business to discuss, Chairperson Matranga adjourned the September 17, 2026,
Charter Review Committee Meeting at 6:05 P.M.
Attest:
Raqu 1 art nez, TRMC, City Secr